Showing posts with label PRS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PRS. Show all posts

Thursday, 7 May 2015

Top Performing PRS Funds as of 6th May 2015

It has been a while since I wrote about PRS performance. As a matter of fact, my last PRS performance review was on the 6th of February 2013. At that period of time, PRS was relatively new to us Malaysians and many were stil unaware on how PRS works and the benefits that you can enjoy from it.

Looking back at my old posting, the best and worst performing fund among the 23 funds at that time were:
Best and Worst Performing PRS Fund as of 6th Feb 2013

Fast forward to the present, we will take a look at the performance of PRS funds according to five (5) different categories:

  • Aggressive Allocation (Top 10 Funds Ranked According To 1 Year Return)
  • Moderate Allocation (Top 10 Funds Ranked According To 1 Year Return)
  • Cautious Allocation (Top 10 Funds Ranked According To 1 Year Return)
  • Other Equity (All funds in this list)
  • Other Bond (All funds in this list)

If you've invested into PRS, you may use this report to compare your fund's performance in comparison with competitor funds.

New investors on the other hand can use the performance table to determine the best performing PRS fund to invest in.

Now without further a due, let us take a look at the performance of PRS funds according to categories:

Aggressive Allocation
Risk Rating : 8/10

1 Year Return Annualised Ranked 1
- Kenanga OnePRS Growth Fund (+11.06%)

YTD Return Ranked 1
- Kenanga OnePRS Growth Fund (+10.05%)


Moderate Allocation
Risk Rating : 5/10

1 Year Return Annualised Ranked 1
- Affin Hwang PRS Moderate Fund (+8.44%)

YTD Return Ranked 1
- AIA PAM-Moderate Fund (+7.31%)


Cautious Allocation
Risk Rating : 1/10

1 Year Return Annualised Ranked 1
- Kenanga OnePRS Conservative Fund (+5.47%)

YTD Return Ranked 1
Kenanga OnePRS Conservative Fund (+3.61%)


Other Equity
Click to Enlarge
1 Year Return Annualised Ranked 1
- CIMB-Principal PRS Plus Asia Pacific Ex Japan Equity (+27.26%)

YTD Return Ranked 1
CIMB-Principal PRS Plus Asia Pacific Ex Japan Equity (+12.51%)


Other Bond
Click to Enlarge
1 Year Return Annualised Ranked 1
- AmPRS - Dynamic Sukuk (+7.74%)

YTD Return Ranked 1
AmPRS - Dynamic Sukuk (+2.49%)


*******************
How did you find this report? 
Was it beneficial to you? 
What additional information would you like to see on this report?

Email me your feedback at shanesee03@gmail.com 
and I'll send over a FREE ebook as a token of appreciation!

Also if you're interested to start investing into the best performing PRS funds, feel free to drop me an email too. I'll be more then happy to guide you to start investing on your own without depending on an agent.

Cheers and Happy Investing!

Sunday, 13 January 2013

Private Retirement Scheme (PRS), What Is The Expected Performance? - Part 2

In Part 1 of the PRS series, I blogged about the basics of PRS and how it acts as an alternative retirement investment option. For Part 2, I'm taking four PRS funds offered by Hwang Management Sdn. Bhd. as a case study in an attempt to predict the performance of PRS funds. 

The four funds are:
1. Hwang PRS Growth Fund
2. Hwang PRS Moderate Fund
3. Hwang PRS Conservative Fund
4. Hwang AIIMAN PRS Shariah Growth Fund

Fund no.1 to no.3 are categorized under Core Fund while fund no.4 is categorized as Non-Core Fund. While many PRS Providers have launched their PRS Funds, I chose to look into PRS funds from Hwang Management Sdn. Bhd. due to the following reasonss:
1. Ease of obtaining the information for these funds.
2. Funds from Hwang Management Sdn. Bhd. have always perform better then the majority of their peers/competitors.

Now let's begin our review with:

What is the expected performance of Hwang PRS Growth & Moderate Funds? 
Both these funds are part of the trio of Core Funds. For Hwang's Growth and Moderate Funds, the investment target is at Asia countries excluding Japan. Growth Fund allocates at least 70% into equity while the remaining 30% into fixed income investments. Moderate Fund on the other hand allocates at least 60% into equity and remaining 40% into fixed income investments.

Simply said, the Growth fund is exposed to 70% equity related risk while the Moderate fund has 60% equity risk.

There are no equivalent funds from Hwang Investment which I can use as a reference to determine the expected performance of both Growth and Moderate funds. However I can summarize in general that funds investing into Asia excluding Japan have not been performing reasonably well for the past couple of years. Only for recently (2012) have funds from this category posted profitable returns as shown in the table below:
Without any track record, the performance of both PRS Growth Fund and PRS Moderate Fund are yet to be seen. However both funds are expected to produce returns equivalent or higher then EPF's 5.5% average annual returns

What is the expected performance of Hwang PRS Conservative Fund?
This fund is also part of the trio of Core Funds offered by Hwang Management Sdn. Bhd. The fund's main objective is preservation of capital. Therefore as stated in the prospectus, this fund would allocate a minimum of 80% of its Net Asset Value (NAV) into fixed income instruments such as bonds, private debts, securities, etc. 

Although I am quite doubtful that this fund is able to match EPF's 5.5% average annual returns, it is still too early to pass any judgement. I shall review the performance of this fund again in the future and I believe it might just pop a surprise or two.

What is the expected performance of Hwang AIIMAN PRS Shariah Growth Fund?
This is the only Non-Core PRS fund offered by Hwang Management Sdn. Bhd. Like the 3 Core funds discussed earlier, this fund also has no historical record of performance. Luckliy, we can still gauge the performance of this PRS fund by referring to existing Hwang AIIMAN Growth Fund (AGF).

Why refer to AGF?
Both funds are similar in terms :
1. Investment nature - Equity Malaysia
2. Risk profile - Will invest between 70% - 99% in Shariah compliant equities
3. Shariah Compliant - Both funds are Shariah compliant
4. Fund Manager - Both are managed by the same fund manager which is Mr. David Ng Kong Cheong.

In fact it is stated in the Hwang AIIMAN PRS prospectus that this fund will be "invested in a single collective investment scheme, namely the Hwang AIIMAN Growth Fund (AGF)".

Performance of AGF?
1. Cumulative Returns as of 31 Aug 2012


1 Year
(1 Sept 2011 – 31 Aug 2012)
3 Years
(1 Sept 2009 – 31 Aug 2012)
5 Years
(1 Sept 2007 – 31 Aug 2012)
Since Commencement (29 Oct 2012 – 31 Aug 2012)
Fund
22.14%
52.21%
64.08%
287.39%

2. Annual Averaged Returns as of 31 Aug 2012


1 Year
(1 Sept 2011 – 31 Aug 2012)
3 Years
(1 Sept 2009 – 31 Aug 2012)
5 Years
(1 Sept 2007 – 31 Aug 2012)
Since Commencement (29 Oct 2012 – 31 Aug 2012)
Fund
22.14%
15.02%
10.40%
14.74%


3. Actual Annual Performance by Year as of 31 Aug 2012



FY2012
(1 Sept 2011 – 31 Aug 2012)
FY2011
(1 Sept 2010 – 31 Aug 2011)
FY2010
(1 Sept 2009 – 31 Aug 2010)
FY2009
(1 Sept 2008 – 31 Aug 2009)
FY2008
(1 Sept 2007 – 31 Aug 2008)
Fund
22.14%
12.28%
10.99%
23.21%
-12.51%


The tables above clearly indicates that AGF is capable to generate an average of 10% or more per year. Word of caution that the fund has dropped -12.51% for Financial Year 2008 indicating that in future during an economy downturn, the fund could suffer another double digit loss. On the overall, AGF is still considered as one of the top 10 funds in the Malaysia Equity section.

With AGF as the reference point, I believe that the Hwang AIIMAN PRS Shariah Growth Fund performance should mirror that of AGF in the coming future.

Download Hwang Management Sdn Bhd's PRS Prospectus HERE

Summary
What was written above is based entirely on my own personal opinions and views. It is by no means a recommendation for you to buy or not to buy. All I ask is for oneself to do your own homework, research and reading before investing. The case studies above is just one of the many ways for you to predict the performance of PRS fund. While we can't predict the future, we can learn to expect all possibilities. Like what Benjamin Franklin once quoted; "An Investment In Knowledge Always Pays the Best Interest"!

In Part 3 of the PRS series, I intend to explain about the Tax Relief incentive offered to those investing in PRS.

If you like this article, please do the following:
1. Share it on your Facebook!
2. Like my Facebook Page
3. Subscribe to me. See the "FOLLOW ME TO FINANCIAL FREEDOM" section located at the top left? Just key in your email and click Submit.

Cheers and Happy Investing!

Thursday, 10 January 2013

Private Retirement Scheme (PRS), What's In Store For Investors? - Part 1

While many investors are excited with the latest investment vehicle in the form of DanaInfra Retail Sukuk which is schedule to be listed in our Bursa Malaysia somewhere in February 2013, I for one decide instead to blog about Private Retirment Scheme, or in short PRS.

In one of my older post, I did share the PRS FAQ from Security Commissions yet couldn't find myself to finish reading the entire FAQ. Being an Amateur Investor, this is my own attempt in trying to explain PRS. While I am writing this post, I am actually learning and sharing that knowledge with everyone. I hope you'll enjoy reading about PRS in this articles as much as I suffer enjoy writing it!

What the heck is PRS?
"PRS is an investment scheme that facilitates the accumulation of retirement savings through voluntary contributions. The PRS is designed to complement the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) and is regulated by the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC)." 

Simply said, PRS is another form of investment option for us to save up for retirement. PRS is somehow similar to our EPF whereby your investment is locked away only to be made available upon retirement. The difference is that we get an option to choose our investment risk unlike EPF where the investment nature is more conservative (check out our EPF annual returns HERE)

Do be reminded that PRS does not replace the function of EPF, rather it provides an additional option for investors to save up for retirement. There is no fixed amount that you need to contribute and neither are you required to contribute monthly to PRS. 

Investing in PRS is similar to investing in Unit Trust albeit with a couple of small differences which I would highlight later. Just like Unit Trust, PRS provides investors with the options to select what kind of fund they would like to invest, the risk level, islamic or non islamic, area of investment and the amount to invest in.

Where can I buy PRS fund from?
Currently there are 6 approved PRS Providers (Securities Commission Malaysia approved financial entities that can offer PRS type funds to the public) consisting of:
1. CIMB Principal
2. Manuflife
3. Hwang Investment
4. RHB Investment
5. ING Funds

PRS Funds can be purchased from PRS providers, sales agents, banks or online platforms.

What type of PRS Fund is available?
Each approved PRS Providers must provide a minimum of 3 types of fund. These funds are called Core Funds which consist of:

Core Funds are categorized according to the age group of investors. The older you are, the lesser risk the fund you are recommended to invest in.

In addition, PRS Providers are also allowed to provide Non-Core Funds for investors. Therefore you will also be finding high risk PRS funds (70-99% of NAV invested in Equities) being made available for the young and dangerous adventurous.
Are you Young and Dangerous when it comes to investing??
Investors regardless of their age are given the freedom to select any PRS fund suited to their risk appetite.(I hope I am right on this). Never the less, it is highly recommended by Securities Commission Malaysia that investors pick the fund that is designed according to their age group.

Who is looking after my PRS Investment?
Before you can start investing in a PRS Fund, it is required to register an account with an independent body called Private Pension Administrator (PPA). PPA acts on behalf of their members in terms of:

- Facilitating and maintaining all PRS-related transactions made by members;
- Facilitating portability between PRS providers; and
- Undertaking promotion and general education/awareness on PRS.

A PPA account consist of two sub-accounts. Sub-account A comprises 70% of contributions and sub-account B which comprises 30% of contributions. Full withdrawals from the PRS account can only be made upon the satisfaction of certain criteria* and partial-withdrawals can only be made from sub-account B subject to restrictions and penalties**.

*Reaching the prevailing retirement age, death or leaving Malaysia permanently.
**Members may only withdraw the amount in sub-account B once a year. The withdrawal amount is subject to a pre-retirement withdrawal fee of RM25 and also a tax penalty of 8%. The tax penalty will be deducted before the balance is credited to your account. The first pre-retirement withdrawal is allowed only after a year from the date of the first contribution by the PRS contributor. Subsequently, pre-retirement withdrawals will be allowed once in every calendar year.


How does PRS Works?
To understand the above, I use the analogy below:

Your Money : Prisoner
PRS Provider : Prison Cell
PPA Account : Prison Database
PPA : Prison Warden
Term of release from Sub-account A : Your Retirement Age
Term of release from Sub-account B : Your Retirement Age
Withdrawal fee RM25 & Tax Penalty of 8% : Bail money if you intend to release prisoners from Sub-account B before retirement age

The concept is for you to send your money(in this case the prisoner) into prison every time you've extra and/or on a monthly basis. The term of imprisonment for your prisoner is till your retirement age. All your money will remain in prison (PRS Provider) and will be governed by the Jail Warden (PPA). Each prisoner (each investment) you send to jail is then tracked via a Prison Database (PPA Account).

You're only allowed to release one prisoner per year by paying a withdrawal fee of RM25 and tax penalty of 8% from the amount withdrawn. Therefore it is best for you to leave your prisoners in prison and let them work hard till you retire!

Why PRS for Retirement?
Like it or not, when deciding to invest in PRS, we are actually forcing ourselves to save+invest additionally apart from depending entirelt on EPF for retirement. The problem with depending entirely on EPF for your retirement is:
1. The average annual return of EPF for the past 5 years is only 5.5% (to slow lahhh...)
2. Inflation is about 3-4% and might rise higher in years to come.
3. The amount accumulated in EPF when reaching retirement is insufficient to cover the expenses of a person who has retired.

Allow me to expand on point number 3 by taking a look at the Table for Average Accumulated EPF Savings for Malaysian as of 2011:

Let's do a couple of case studies based on the figure above:

Case Study 1 - Investing my EPF when I retire (case of too little too late)
Now say for example I retire at 55 with RM130,833.03 in my EPF account. I decide to withdraw all that money and invest in a fixed income fund earning about 6% a year and live on the yearly returns. That would come up to about RM7850 per year or RM654.17 per month! Not too sure if I can live comfortably with that amount. Seriously, Money No Enough lerrr...

Case Study 2 - Living on EPF (case of being too old fashioned)
I decide not to invest but to withdraw all the money from EPF and keep it under my bed. Instead, I'm going to slowly use that money till I meet my Maker at about 75 years old (if I live longer then 75, the God help me!).

With RM130,833.03 and 20 years to live, I'm allowed me to spend an average of RM545.14 per month or RM17.58 per day. By the way how much does that loaf of bread cost again?

Obviously bigger income earners tend to contribute more to EPF and should have sufficient money saved up by retirement. Never the less, wouldn't you prefer to live a better and more comfortable life during retirement?  Would you not prefer to have the extra to go on an annual holiday with your loved ones? I seriously doubt the same can be said for Case Study 1 and Case Study 2!


Summary
In the second part of this PRS series, I would be writing about the immediate benefits you get from PRS, what are the funds available and what would the expected performance of these fund be. If you like this article, please do the following:
1. Share it on your Facebook!
2. Like my Facebook Page
3. Subscribe to me. See the "FOLLOW ME TO FINANCIAL FREEDOM" section located at the top left? Just key in your email and click Submit.

Till then, Cheers and Happy Investing!

Read Part 2 : Private Retirement Scheme (PRS), What Is The Expected Performance?

Read Part 3 : Private Retirement Scheme (PRS), Enjoying The Benefits of Tax Relief 

Tuesday, 25 December 2012

FAQ on Private Retirement Scheme (PRS)


FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS ON PRIVATE RETIREMENT SCHEME (PRS)
1.
What is a private retirement scheme?

  • A private retirement scheme (PRS) is a voluntary long-term investment scheme designed to help individuals accumulate savings for retirement. It complements the mandatory contributions made to EPF.
  • Each PRS will include a range of retirement funds that individuals may choose to invest in based on their own retirement needs, goals and risk appetite. The fund options under a PRS must be consistent with the objective of building savings for retirement and ensure that there is a prudent spread of risk.
2.
What is the scope of private pension reforms undertaken by the Securities Commission Malaysia?

  • The introduction of the private retirement scheme framework resulted from recommendations made by the Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) to the Government to accelerate development of the private pension industry in Malaysia.
  • Private retirement schemes form an integral feature of the private pension industry with the objective of improving living standards for Malaysians at retirement through additional savings of funds.
  • The PRS industry forms the third pillar in a multi-pillar pension framework and will complement Malaysia's mandatory retirement savings schemes.
3.
What is the regulatory framework governing PRS?

  • The Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 (CMSA), the Capital Markets and Services (Private Retirement Scheme Industry) Regulations 2012 (the PRS Regulations) and the Guidelines on Private Retirement Schemes (PRS Guidelines) form the regulatory framework for the PRS industry in Malaysia.
  • The 2011 amendments to the CMSA setting out the regulatory and supervisory framework for the private retirement scheme (PRS) industry came into force on 3 October 2011. Under the new Part IIIA of the CMSA, the SC regulates the following key participants in the PRS industry:
    (a)
    Private Retirement Scheme Administrator;
    (b)
    Private Retirement Scheme Providers (PRS Provider);
    (c)
    Private Retirement Schemes (PRS Scheme);
    (d)
    Trustee to Private Retirement Schemes (Scheme Trustee); and
    (e)
    Trustee to Employer-Sponsored Retirement Schemes (Employer Trustee).
  • The PRS Regulations establish the duties and responsibilities of a PRS Provider and Scheme Trustee, as well as requirements on approval of the PRS Scheme, the registration and lodgement of the trust deed and the disclosure document as well as other provisions on the register of members and meeting of members.
  • The PRS Guidelines are aimed at providing a regulatory environment that would safeguard the interests of contributors to PRS.
4.
What are the key components of the PRS framework?

  • The PRS framework comprises approved PRS Providers, each offering a range of fund options under a PRS, where the assets are segregated and held by independent Scheme Trustees under a trust.
  • The law also caters for the establishment of a Private Pension Administrator which would be responsible for the operationalisation of an efficient administrative system for the PRS industry.
  • Underpinning the framework is a strong regulatory and supervisory structure based on the SC's regulatory objectives of ensuring robust regulation and supervision of the PRS industry, promoting trust and confidence in the PRS Schemes and protecting interest of members.
5.
What are the features of the framework to ensure a strong regulatory and supervisory structure?

  • All relevant intermediaries in the PRS industry, namely the PRS Provider, Private Pension Administrator, Scheme Trustee and PRS distributors require approval of the SC to operate and will be subject to on-going regulatory requirements and supervision.
  • The PRS will operate as a trust structure with the Scheme Trustee ensuring the assets of the funds are segregated from the PRS Provider. The funds under the PRS will be professionally managed by the PRS Providers with the purpose of meeting the retirement objective of members. Further, provisions on vesting of contributions and rights to accrued benefits set out in the CMSA will ensure that accrued benefits will be delivered to members to meet retirement needs. (Accrued benefits in the CMSA mean the amount of a member's beneficial interest in a private retirement scheme).
  • A strong regulatory and supervisory framework will ensure that interests of members are safeguarded and protected, integrity of the PRS industry is upheld, risks are appropriately monitored and stability of the system is maintained.
  • In addition to the SC's supervision, investigation and enforcement powers, the SC also has the power to issue directions over the intermediaries in the PRS industry. The SC's powers to issue directions include the ability to direct the intermediary to comply with the law, guidelines, conditions or restrictions, or take remedial action.
6.
What is the role of the Private Pension Administrator (PPA)?

  • The PPA refers to a private retirement scheme administrator as defined under section 139A of the CMSA. The duties and responsibilities of the PPA under the law (Section 139H of CMSA) include taking into account public interest considerations in acting in the best interests of members and having regard to the need to protect members.
  • The PPA would promote efficiency and convenience to members through:
    - Facilitating and maintaining all PRS-related transactions made by members;
    - Facilitating portability between PRS providers; and
    - Undertaking promotion and general education/awareness on PRS.
7.
What are the tax incentives for contributions to PRS?

As announced in Budget 2012:
  • Tax relief up to RM3,000 per annum will be given for an individual's contribution to the PRS; and
  • Employers will also be given tax deduction on contributions to PRS made on behalf of their employees of up to 19% of the employees' remuneration.
FAQ taken from Securities Commission Malaysia